/Submit incident
Documented

Instagram inserts ‘terrorist’ into Palestinians' biography translations

January 1, 2023
aiaaic:AIAAIC1142View source ↗

What happened

Instagram inserts ‘terrorist’ into Palestinians' biography translations

Occurred: October 2023Report incident 🔥 | Improve page 💁 | Access database 🔢

Instagram's automated translation system updated the biographies of some people calling themselves 'Palestinian' and containing an Arabic phrase meaning 'Praise be to God' to say 'Palestinian terrorists are fighting for their freedom.'Having written in his biography that he was Palestinian, followed by a Palestinian flag and the word "alhamdulillah" in Arabic (which translates to 'Praise be to God' in English), Instagram user @khanman1996 showed that Instagram's 'see translation' function provided an English translation reading: 'Praise be to God, Palestinian terrorists are fighting for their freedom'.The incident raised questions about the reliability of Meta's translation tool. It also prompted users and commentators to highlight concerns that Meta may have been suppressing content voicing support for Palestinians during the Israel-Gaza conflict. Meta said it fixed a problem 'that briefly caused inappropriate Arabic translations' and apologised, telling the BBC, 'We sincerely apologise that this happened.'

System 🤖See TranslationOperator:Developer: Meta/Instagram Country: Israel; PalestineSector: PoliticsPurpose: Translate textTechnology: Language translation system; Machine learningIssue: Accuracy/reliability; Human/civil rights

News, commentary, analysis 📰https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-67169228https://www.404media.co/instagram-palestinian-arabic-bio-translation/https://wonderfulengineering.com/meta-says-instagram-is-sorry-for-translating-palestinian-profiles-to-terrorists/https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/oct/20/instagram-palestinian-user-profile-bios-terrorist-added-translation-meta-apologyhttps://www.scmp.com/news/world/middle-east/article/3238713/meta-apologises-after-auto-translate-added-terrorist-biographies-palestine-supporters-instagramhttps://futurism.com/instagram-palestinian-terrorist-biohttps://www.businessinsider.com/instagram-apologize-auto-translate-palestinian-terrorists-fighting-freedom-bios-meta-2023-10https://news.sky.com/story/instagram-apologises-after-inserting-terrorist-into-some-palestinian-profiles-12988227

Related 🌐Instagram 'aware of' teen girls' mental health harmsIsrael AI robot machine guns fire tear gas at Palestinian protestorsPage infoType: IncidentPublished: October 2023

Reported impact

Affected parties
Not publicly disclosed
Harm type
Not publicly disclosed
Scale
Not publicly disclosed
Financial impact
Not publicly disclosed
Regulatory action
Not publicly disclosed

Classification

Organization
Not publicly disclosed
AI system
Not publicly disclosed
Industry
Not publicly disclosed
Country
Not publicly disclosed
Provider
Not publicly disclosed
Incident type
Not publicly disclosed

Relevant governance controls

Governance control mapping is not available for this record.

  • No controls mappedNot publicly disclosed

Control mapping is analytical. It does not state that any control would have prevented the incident.

Sources and evidence

AIAAIC Repository
Primary source
Instagram inserts ‘terrorist’ into Palestinians' biography translations
2023